Mike wrote:
It really isn't even about how many shows you play it is how consistently you draw big crowds.
Very good point.
Consistency is everything. I've been booking shows since October 2000 and I'm still at it, because I've been consistent in my business dealings. I called Kevin Gunther today and he was happy to hear from me, because we've been doing business for years now and we both know what to expect from each other.
I've made mistakes, sure. But I always fix them. My biggest mistake was not communicating with local bands better about show finances. I think we've addressed that and things are now going smoother, both directions. Some promoters hide who they've booked, but I don't. Ask bands I've booked and you hear the same things, 5+ years later. Ask me about bands I've been booking for years like Westbound Train and The Know How and you'll hear a consistent story. Some of us are in this for the long haul.

In the article cited, they also wrote:
"This is a business built entirely upon relationships and reputation," said Dutch Seyfarth, a local musician and promoter.
Again, I'm amazed how many bands don't get this simple concept. You legitimately befriend people who hook up your band and then you stay loyal to those people. The whole music business is based on that.
Bucket of The Toasters and I had mutual respect before I ever booked them the very first time. And we've simply built on that foundation. I just really don't get these young bands who ask for shows, show up to play and then disappear until they want another show. I don't know any decent bands or promoters who work like that, sorry.